Book Club Review: Me, Earl and the Dying Girl by Jesse Andrews

me earl

Title: Me, Earl and the Dying Girl

Author: Jesse Andrews

Genre: Young Adult, Fiction, Contemporary, Comedy

This book contains precisely zero Important Life Lessons, or Little-Known Facts About Love, or sappy tear-jerking Moments When We Knew We Had Left Our Childhood Behind for Good, or whatever.

Goodreads | The Book Depository


summary

Amateur film maker Greg Gaines is encouraged by his mother to befriend an old acquaintance who is dying of cancer.

review

One thing I’ve learned about people is that the easiest way to get them to like you is to shut up and let them do the talking. Everyone likes to talk about themselves.

I have to start really by saying that I thought this book was hilarious. The narrative style – rambling monologue – is a perfect fit for Greg’s humorous persona. It won’t be for everyone – I would only recommend it to a third of the bookworms I know – but it was perfect for me and the sarcastic, dark comedy I love.

One night Mom had a little too much wine at dinner and confided to us all that, before we were born, and after she realized her children would have Dad’s also-not-Jewish last name, she decided she wanted all of us to be “surprise Jews.” Meaning, Jews with sneaky Anglo-Saxon names. I know, it makes no sense. I guess it shows that a vulnerability to brain fungus runs in the family.

Greg is the most honest protagonist I have ever met, and the perspective is refreshing and shocking. His narrative is blunt, which gives the impression that everything we are reading is authentic.

There are a lot of home truths in this book. Greg is a very self-centered protagonist and this is constantly reinforced throughout the book. This was something I picked up on in my Checkpoint post the other day, before I had even finished the book. This is a story not about Rachel the “dying girl”, but about Greg. He is egocentric, and when he realises his character flaw, it is too late. I hoped his epiphany would happen while Rachel was still alive. I really think I had been lulled into The Land of False Hope by other YA books, believing that right at the last minute, Greg would fall in love and Rachel would find the will to continue her battle with cancer. Or at the very least, I was hoping there would be some kind of romance subplot – I know The Fault In Our Stars didn’t end happily but there had been love and that had given the death (not being too specific about said death as this isn’t the place for spoiling OTHER books) more emotional impact. When Rachel died there was a surprising realness to it. It just happened rather anticlimactically. Greg didn’t get the girl (he didn’t want the girl), and yet either way the girl was going to die. There is something in that which I find more shocking in some ways than TFIOS.

This book probably makes it seem like I hate myself and everything I do. But that’s not totally true. I mostly just hate every person I’ve ever been. I’m actually fine with myself right now.

I really like the contrast in personalities between Greg and Earl. I didn’t really dig Earl particularly, but I admired that he had the insight to see that Rachel deserved their attention. I did wonder if this rare tenderness shown by Earl was hinting at a potential romance (*hopeful face*) but Greg was so caught up with himself that I don’t think he even would have noticed.

The book never pretends to be something it is not, and there’s a life lesson buried in there somewhere I think, about not knowing what you’ve got until it is gone.

The most beautiful thing about you is that you’re not a sock puppet.

Star Rating: ☆☆☆☆ (4/5)

Emma

Follow me on: Twitter | Tumblr | Instagram

Previous Post Next Post

6 Comments

  • Reply thebibliotheque

    Great review! I had no idea this book was written in that sarcastic dark-ish tone, I was never convinced to add this to my tbr but now it’s definitely going in there 🙂

    November 1, 2015 at 9:23 am
    • Reply Emma @ Wandering Words

      Yeah, I was surprised by how tongue-in-cheek it was, considering the subject matter. I felt that the humour was a coping strategy for the protagonist, a way of distancing himself from Rachel’s illness. Let me know if/when you read it – I’d love to know if you interpret it in the same way!

      November 1, 2015 at 10:16 am
  • Reply Top Ten Tuesday: Ten Book To Movie Adaptations I Still Need To Watch | Wandering Words

    […] reading the book recently for October’s Book Club (review found here), I know this will be a hilarious […]

    November 10, 2015 at 8:06 am
  • Reply Five Book Ideas For Your Friends This Christmas | Wandering Words

    […] Perfect for… People who found The Fault In Our Stars just too soppy. This book takes its own very unique approach to terminal illness in young people; it is tongue-in-cheek – with classic lines like ‘the most beautiful thing about you is that you are not a sock puppet’ – but it is honest, and tears are still likely to be shed.  This book was read in October for the Words & Geeks Book Club, and it did not disappoint!  Review available here. […]

    December 8, 2015 at 12:08 pm
  • Reply Ten Books On My Fall TBR - Wandering Words

    […] Review available to read here. […]

    May 18, 2016 at 10:43 am
  • Leave a comment!

    You may also like